Becoming a Catholic

Ethan


“Although there was enough that I disagreed with in the [Catholic] church, it consistently taught that Jesus had a deep concern for the poor and that living right and treating others right was core to what it is to be a Christian. Besides, I wanted to participate in the beautiful liturgy I was making music for three, four, five times a week.”


Edited by Cliff Williams from an interview with Ethan on September 11, 2026. "Ethan" is a pseudonym.   


Early Childhood

My father grew up in a Catholic family and became an atheist when he went to university. His older brother followed the same path. About five or six years before I was born, the older brother experienced a radical conversion, becoming a charismatic Pentecostal and experiencing the gifts of the Spirit. He quit drinking, using drugs, partying, and felt called to become a missionary in North Africa.


My dad said, “Wow, that is tremendous. This is my deadbeat brother who has had a change I can’t argue with. I need to find out what it’s all about.” My dad came to believe in the Lord Jesus when he was twenty-four, about two years before I was born, just as he was getting to know my mom. My mom was raised in a charismatic evangelical church. 


From the beginning of their marriage, the two of them were vibrant in their faith. They believed first and foremost that Jesus Christ was to be at the center of their lives and that the formation of their children had to begin with that. So growing up I was surrounded by Christian worship and practice.


When I was two-and-a-half years old, I came to understand that I needed to accept Jesus Christ as my personal savior. I said something like the sinner’s prayer: “I’m a bad person. I can’t save myself. I need you to save me. I make you the Lord of my life.” I was very pleased with myself and told my family. Everyone celebrated.


About that time, we switched to a different church. I had become aware that different Christians have different beliefs, and you don’t know what is true unless you can justify it from the Bible. Certain churches are better than other churches, and we have to go to a church that is actually doing what God told us to do in the Bible. 


When I was about five-and-a-half, we started going to a Plymouth Brethren church. It was an open Brethren church, which was a bit more open-minded than a closed Brethren church. This distinction was very important to us, and anyone you knew who fell on the other side of the line was clearly an apostate and going to hell.


We spent three hours on Sunday mornings at the church. The first hour was spent in what was called the Lord’s Supper. We gathered in silence. If someone felt that the Lord was leading them to read a passage of scripture or suggest that the assembly sing a hymn or pray, they did so. If no one felt compelled to say anything, we sat in silence. Toward the end of that hour, bread and grape juice were given thanks for and passed around the room. Then there was a Sunday School hour, and after that the Family Bible Hour. We sang hymns during the last hour and listened to a forty-five to fifty-minute sermon. There was also a Wednesday night meeting that I went to. I felt quite at home in that church, and the people were truly kind to me and my family. That was my whole world as a kid.


We were concerned about having contact with kids who were not saved, who were not evangelicals, lest they be a worldly influence. We had neighbors whom I barely talked to because my parents were concerned that they might use profane language or tempt me to do something bad or otherwise lead me astray. We very much had the assumption that people who were saved were safe and anyone who was not, or who was a different sort of Christian or had a different religion or no religion, was suspect. You should have contact with them only insofar as you had a chance to witness to them and convert them.  


My experiences in these churches prompted a good deal of fear. If someone was outside our social circle, we didn’t know whether they were going to abduct us. We children were homeschooled, and we feared having Child Protective Services called and having our parents taken away and we children put into some kind of Dickensian orphanage.


These experiences made me struggle to make new friends outside of my prescribed social setting. I was always suspicious of new people I met. I assumed they had an ulterior motive or that suddenly the neighbor who wanted to hear about my day could turn me into an alcoholic or do some other horrible thing to me.


We were members of the Homeschool Legal Defense Association, the HSLDA, which sent a magazine that said homeschooling parents should under no circumstances open their door to a truancy officer or to Child Protective Services. The government was out to get you, and they wanted to make an example of faithful Christians who were homeschooling their children. So keep your kids away from anyone who was in a position to report you.


All these experiences strengthened my childhood faith. There are warnings in scripture about what the world loves being evil and what the world hates being praiseworthy and good. Jesus said, “If the world hates you, it hated me before it hated you” (John 15:18). So if people hated us or we were different from others, that meant we were doing something right. As a young kid, I didn’t think it could be otherwise.


When I was six and a half, there was a testimony night at church. A man who was in his eighties got up and told the story of how he had been converted at age twelve. I thought to myself, “What if I didn’t really mean it when I was two and a half or didn’t really understand it? What if I didn’t adequately convince Jesus Christ that I wanted him to be my personal savior? Then I’m going to hell. So I better fix that real quick.” I prayed: “Lord, you know I want to be your child. I want to do what you want me to do.” At that point, I became certain once again that I was among the saved.


I started piano lessons when I was seven. The woman who played the organ at church caught wind of a young person learning music and took me under her wing. She put me to work playing for Sunday services, which I did every Sunday at age eight onward. That was a tremendous thing for me, and it became part of my childhood identity. With the talent God had given me, I could play for three hundred people who were singing at the top of their lungs to praise God. I was on a mission. I needed to live right so that I could praise God well and other people could praise God too and want to become Christians. I still feel the same way now as a church organist.


Later Childhood

I ticked along pretty happily until I was eleven or twelve when my parents came in contact with more conservative evangelicals, people at the Old Order Mennonite end of the spectrum. My sisters started to wear a veil or headscarf, not just in church on Sunday as the Plymouth Brethren did, but all the time, even at home. 


My dad began listening to preaching about whether it was right for there to be Sunday schools or other church programs that divided up young people from old people or children by grade level. I think the basis for that was in Ezra or Nehemiah where it says that the book of the law was being read to the whole assembly of the Israelites. The men were there, the women were there, and the children were there. So the preachers my dad was listening to inferred that good religious training got done when men, women, and children were together. I didn’t quite see that, but my dad had the car and he came to the conclusion that we needed to stop going to the church we were going to because they were doing the unbiblical thing of having Sunday schools and youth groups for different ages.


When I was thirteen and a half, we started going to an independent, fundamentalist Baptist church. To put that into perspective, if you were from a liberal, dangerously backsliding family, you would send your child to Pensacola Christian College. If you were already one foot out the door on the road to perdition, you would send your child to Bob Jones University. If you were a really good Christian, you might send your boys to Hyles-Anderson Bible College, Golden State Baptist, or to the local Bible institute in a converted garage. But your daughters, absolutely not. They never go to school because they are going to be mothers. 


When we first went to this new church, I was repulsed. The Plymouth Brethren preached in a very measured way, almost as though they were lecturing in a college classroom. Maybe they got excited and raised a finger. But in the new church, they beat on the pulpit and shouted at the top of their lungs. The first couple of services we were there, I counted the number of times the preacher mentioned Jesus and the number of times he talked about things he didn’t like, such as women wearing pants or men not wearing a tie to church and other arbitrary things he couldn’t back up from scripture. I sat there and thought, “Okay. He’s mentioned Jesus twice, and it’s been an hour and a half and he keeps yelling about rock and roll music. What is the point of this?” 


I expressed this to my parents: “This is really extreme. It makes me uncomfortable that these people are constantly shouting and not teaching the Bible so much as telling us about all the things they don’t like that you can’t prove one way or the other from scripture.” My parents said, “This church isn’t age segregated. This is where we need to be. You’ll get used to it.” So I knuckled down, being obedient as I should be, saying to myself: “Surely God will bless me and everything will be okay.”

 

I played the piano there and the organ for services. I went on the street preaching team and to rock concerts to yell at people that they were going to hell. I looked for those who appeared to be tattooed or pierced, signs of someone who was not straight, so that I could harangue them and convince them of their sin. People at my church protested the Pride Parade every year. We marched in the July 4th parades. We were very much a God and country church—we need to get America back to its biblical roots and then everybody will be just like us.


I remember hearing some xenophobic and deeply Islamaphobic preaching in the church. That was about the time Obama was running for president, in 2007, 2008. Looking back, I see now that I was in a very racist and hateful environment. But at the time I came to believe all of it very sincerely.


One summer I went to a retreat run by the church for boys in middle school and high school. We lived for a week in tents in a field that had no sanitation of any sort, just a pit and jugs of water. The emphasis that week was that God had a specific purpose for your life and there was nothing else you could do that would please God. If you didn’t follow that purpose, you were not really saved. You very likely had been called to be a missionary or a pastor, because these were the highest callings. If you didn’t choose one of these, you were going to let God down.


There were lectures in the morning, and in the evening we went soul winning in a nearby city. The whole thing was designed to induce some sort of psychosis or at least put you in a vulnerable and susceptible state so that if someone convinced you that you were going to be a missionary to China, you would go with that and take it as your life’s calling. I did not get that call, and so I felt defective.


When I was fifteen, I went to a conference for church musicians put on by Bob Jones University. At the end, there was a sermon about having a call and a particular purpose in your life. I heard God say, “You will serve me through music.” And I said, “Okay. Now I have a call that is just as good as anybody else’s. That is what I’m going to do.”


Confusion

I started taking organ lessons at the nationally known music school in the city in which I lived. I didn’t know it at first, but I learned after a while that my teacher was gay, because he was married to another man at the music school. I became confused. How can this person who is treating me with remarkable kindness and concern for my development as an organist be gay? He was taking a lot of time, even beyond what he was paid for, to help me get things right. How can this be if he’s a Sodomite? That is impossible. The Bible says he is going to hell. Yet he was exemplifying what we Christians considered to be the fruits of the Spirit.

 

I thank God that my teacher didn’t dump me, though I tried in some clumsy way to witness to him and convert him. I came to lessons wearing a polo shirt that said, “Jesus saves,” on the back in giant print.


Then I took music theory courses at the school. One of my teachers could tell that I was struggling a lot, and she befriended me. She told me that she would support me even if I were to fail at an assignment. I found out that she was a lesbian.


“This is really weird,” I thought. “Here are two people who are being super kind to me even though they are gay. But the people at the Baptist church I and my family were going to don’t treat each other very well. How can this be?”


At a secular music camp I went to, I became good friends with kids who were not Christians. They thought that all religion was made up and a load of crap. Again, I thought, “This doesn’t make sense. These guys are treating me kindly, yet they are reprobate sinners.”


At the beginning of my senior year of high school, I began getting bits of information that things were deeply wrong in a lot of fundamentalist Baptist organizations. I got on the internet so that I could know what was going on and pray for the pastors better. I found that the pastors had been indicted on multiple counts of child abuse. One was facing a life sentence. Another in Texas beat a Mexican kid in his Sunday school so severely that the kid was in a coma for seven weeks. I found fifteen or twenty instances of severe abuse and scandal in the independent fundamental Baptist world of which I was a part. I had had no idea about any of it.


I said to my parents, “What is this?” They said, “You can’t believe everything you read on the internet. You have to believe your pastors. And, frankly, you shouldn’t be looking those things up anyway. It’s not suitable. Who cares what the world says about organizations we know are good?”


I brought these things up with a good friend of mine in the church. She said, “I work for a Christian organization in which the leader has tried to molest the interns. And my own father is a serial rapist. He has repeatedly violated me and all of my sisters. We tried to get him arrested and taken to court, but the pastors went as character witnesses and got him off the hook.”


I said, “That is so terrible. How are you still alive?” She said, “I wish I wasn’t alive.” I talked to more people in the church and found more cases of pastors covering things up and the churches siding with the abusers over the children who had been molested.


At that point, I said, “I’m done. I can’t ever go back to the church that I and my family are going to. If there are people in the church who act in such wrong ways even though they claim so strongly to love God and to know what’s true and are able to back up their opinions from the Bible, then ultimately God does not exist.” I spent my senior year of high school being an atheist. That was a classic non sequiter—someone in the church does a bad thing, therefore there is no God. But when you’re seventeen, you don’t think that carefully about the logic of it. 


I had a problem. I had put all my eggs into the basket of becoming an organist. But there were not many secular jobs in organ playing. I would have to spend my life playing songs in churches to an imaginary being. That would be pretty lousy. But, I thought at the time, it was what I had to do, because I couldn’t change careers.


New Experiences

During a summer camp between high school and freshman year of college, I went to different churches to listen to the music at them. I happened to go to an Episcopal church. It was as smoky of an Anglo-Catholic church as you could find. They were celebrating the Feast of Corpus Christi, which is a liturgy celebrating the real presence of Christ in the bread and wine of the Eucharist, or the Lord’s Supper as I had grown up calling it.


The organ playing wasn’t anything like I had heard before. The organist was improvising through the whole mass in a very modern tonal language. Along with the choir singing, the whole service seemed to be a unified whole, almost like an opera that tells one story from beginning to end. There were people of different ethnic backgrounds and sexualities, all hanging out together and kneeling. The kneeling seemed odd to me, because the people in the churches I had gone to didn’t kneel unless it was for an altar call. 


I left the service thinking the church must be some kind of weird cult because of their belief that the bread in the Lord’s Supper actually was God. But I also thought that there had been some tremendously cool music. I was moved by the way it fit together with the rest of the service and with what the pastor preached about. Maybe if there were other churches like it, I could have an interesting career at them as a musician.


At the beginning of my freshman year at the Christian college I went to, I visited a nearby Lutheran church. It was the closest thing to what I had experienced during the summer. There was smoke. There was Gregorian chant. There were all kinds of organ music. “This must be it,” I thought. “I guess I’ll find out what they teach and get in with it.”


In their class for new members, I found out what the church believed: “You are dead in your sins, and on your own you cannot please God. But God loves you and makes the first move to save you in your baptism. You’re going to be okay.” We read the Didache, the Apostolic Confessions, and Justin Martyr.


I decided to keep going to the church. But I continued to believe many of the things I believed in as a child. One of those things was that Black people weren’t as smart as White people. I know that that is a tremendously offensive thing to say, and I apologize for saying it. But that is what I sincerely believed as a teenager. It wasn’t until my sophomore year in college that it was challenged in a theology course I took. “Wow,” I thought. “There is a lot I haven’t thought about, and I think I have a lot of things wrong. I better start again intellectually from square one. I need to make sure of what I believe and be certain that I can justify it. I need to ground my beliefs in respect for persons. That needs to be at the core of who I am.”


I realized that I lacked that respect. I had afforded myself great respect and had felt that others’ needs were subservient to mine. That was a central part of the political libertarianism I was brought up in.


The liturgy at the Lutheran church played a role in my change. The Plymouth Brethren Church was completely non-liturgical. Although it celebrated communion every week, they had no concept of it being the presence of Christ, even in a spiritual way. The idea of the Eucharist being a participation in the body and blood of Jesus was totally new for me. And it was freeing, because I didn’t have to feel that I trusted in my own choice to believe in Christ, as I did between my first and second sinner’s prayers. In the liturgy, God has made a way to experience divine life here on earth through re-receiving the body and blood of Jesus. It was based on a promise Jesus made and not on a choice I may not have made freely or which could be reversed.


Becoming a Catholic

After I graduated from college, I went to a university for two years to get a master’s degree. I played organ mainly in Catholic churches during those years and was appalled at what I saw—homophobia, misbehavior of the clergy, and general shoddy running of the churches. I didn’t ever want to work for Catholics again.


 After I graduated from the university the only job that opened up was at a little Catholic church in a rural area. I would rather have worked in an Episcopal, Presbyterian, or Methodist church, but the job was full-time and the church was near my family. So I took the job, fully expecting the church to be full of hypocrites.


The pastor there, Father Steve, was a tremendous person. Nothing could disturb him—he had a real sense of peace that had stuck with him during sixty years of ministry. He wanted people to live out the gospel. Plus, he had an immense love for church music, and he gave me all the resources I could possibly want. He himself sang and played the organ. We were a perfect match. I wanted to be like him, but didn’t think I could become a Catholic because of their positions on birth control, women’s ordination, and gay rights. I felt like a displaced person in the church even though I felt nourished and uplifted by everything that was going on in it.


Three years later I lost my job because the archdiocese was in bankruptcy due to the sex abuse cases after the Child Victims Act became law. Everyone but the priests, janitors, and finance people were laid off with a one-day notice. 


That was really rough. What were my wife and I going to do? Fortunately, a job came open in the American South. I took it even though we didn’t want to move there. The state we moved to did not feel like a particularly friendly or tolerant state. But having a job was better than sitting on unemployment for an uncertain period of time.


The church there was lily white, and it was very wealthy. I felt out of place because I was in the wrong income bracket. The church felt somewhat like a social club. I didn’t like it at all. 


Fortunately, the city we were in had a beautiful radio station that played a little bit of everything, including long blocks of Black gospel music. It was clear that the people were singing with everything they had. And the musicians were doing things I couldn’t begin to conceive of even after having gotten a master’s degree in music. It was amazing.


I realized the music had gotten slaves through slavery and Black folks through Jim Crow. It went with Martin Luther King Jr. on civil rights marches. It was the music of people who knew what it was like to be in absolute misery and still find a way to keep going and praise God. Whenever I had a free moment, I listened to this music, not organ or choir music.


I began reading Cornel West and Martin Luther King Jr. and listening to Father Pfleger’s sermons out of St. Sabina Church on the south side of Chicago. I came to believe that it wasn’t much use to believe in the God of the philosophers when you were going through hard times. I recognized how much importance Jesus had put on dealing with others, especially the kinds of people mentioned in Matthew 25—those who were naked and needing clothes, homeless and nowhere to stay, thirsty for righteousness, in prison and needing visits. Christianity that was not attentive to these lost its appeal for me. I wanted to learn more about those who said that if you’re going to be a Christian, you have to watch out for your Mexican neighbor and have your trans neighbor’s back. I wanted to know more about the way of relating to a God who acts in history and who actually can bring about a change in your life.


Four years ago, my mom was diagnosed with cancer, and we thought she was going to die. She lived in a northern state, so I started looking for jobs there. I prayed that if God had something good for me, it would become clear. I gave notice at my church, and two weeks later found that the Catholic cathedral in a major Canadian city was hiring for an organist. It was full-time and paid more than I’d ever made in my life. I applied, auditioned, and was successful. We moved there. 


Two years ago I decided to become a Catholic. I did so because I came to believe that it was the one true church and that those who know this but choose to remain outside it cannot be saved.


I struggled with that decision because it was the opposite of what my father had done. And the Catholic church held views contrary to what I had held for a long time with regard to my gay, lesbian, bisexual, and trans friends, whom I welcomed and affirmed. I myself am bisexual. But although there was enough that I disagreed with in the church, it consistently taught that Jesus had a deep concern for the poor and that living right and treating others right was core to what it is to be a Christian. Besides, I wanted to participate in the beautiful liturgy I was making music for three, four, five times a week.


My Faith Now

The day after the birth of our second child, an acquaintance of mine who was a pastor at a nearby Anglican church came to our house with jars of soup, a bouquet of flowers, and a prayer book. He said, “Can I bless your baby?” I thought, “This is really new to receive pastoral care from someone,” because no one from the cathedral I was playing at ever came to check on us. I realized that I had become so sure about Catholicism being right that I had put limits on God and didn’t recognize that he could be at work elsewhere beside the place I thought he was.


So now I draw from all the places where God has met me over the course of my life. Even though I am tied to an institution insofar as I’m its musician, I don’t think of myself as strictly Catholic or strictly Anglican or strictly Lutheran or strictly Plymouth Brethren. I have received gifts from each of these traditions. I now believe that God can draw people in each of them to become conformed to the image of Christ. By being attentive to Pentecostal critiques of Lutheranism and Anglican critiques of Catholicism, I can learn where the blind spots are in each of these traditions and try to find all the good in them in a way that doesn’t make me unfaithful to Jesus Christ. This may not be particularly rigorous intellectually, but I don’t think you ever really arrive until you’ve cracked the buffers at the end of the line that is your life.


I believe in a God who loves me and who has given me more than I ever could have imagined or ever deserved. For some reason I don’t understand, God has not been so kind to others in the world, such as the Palestinians in Gaza right now. I don’t understand why their lives are totally different from mine. But I believe that much of the suffering that they are experiencing and that others experience derives from human choices. I believe in a God who respects us enough to give us free agency. I believe in a Christianity that teaches us how we can use that gift of freedom in a way that betters our fellow humans rather than contributing to their misery. 


I don’t have everything figured out. But I do believe in a God whose message tells me that things are not the way they’re meant to be, and I better get to work putting them right.


Faith Journeys: Belief and Unbelief

Home page